When you sign your mortgage, you’re often offered mortgage loan insurance, also called mortgage life insurance. It can seem convenient, but it works very differently from personal life insurance: the beneficiary, the amount covered and portability are not the same. Here are the key differences so you can compare the two with full knowledge of the facts before deciding.
Two types of insurance that are often confused
First, let’s clarify a point that causes confusion. The mortgage default insurance required when your down payment is small (from a mortgage insurer such as CMHC) protects the lender if the borrower stops paying. It doesn’t protect your family. This article is instead about the life insurance (and sometimes disability or critical illness insurance) offered by the lender, which pays off the loan balance if you die. This coverage is optional: a lender cannot suggest that it is mandatory to get your loan.
The 4 main differences
1. The beneficiary
With the insurance offered by the lender, it’s the lender that receives the benefit, and it’s used to pay off the loan. With personal life insurance, you’re the one who designates the beneficiary. Your family receives the money and decides how to use it: pay off the mortgage, keep a low-rate loan and use the money another way, pay for the children’s education, and so on.
2. Coverage that decreases
According to the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, the benefit from the lender’s mortgage insurance corresponds to the loan balance, which decreases as you make payments, while the premium generally stays the same. Personal life insurance instead provides a chosen amount that usually stays level for the term of the contract.
3. Portability
The lender’s insurance is tied to your loan. If you switch lenders at renewal, move to Laval or Terrebonne or refinance, the coverage doesn’t necessarily follow you, and you might have to qualify again, at an older age and with health that may have changed. A personal policy belongs to you, regardless of your lender.
4. Assessment of your health
The Agency states that pre-existing health conditions are generally not covered by these products and recommends reading the certificate before enrolling. In some cases, the assessment at enrolment may be brief, which can lead to more in-depth checks at the time of a claim. Individual insurance, on the other hand, is generally fully assessed before the policy is issued. Ask the question and read the summary you’re given carefully.
For official information, see the Agency’s page Optional mortgage insurance products.
Questions to ask yourself before choosing
When signing at the notary’s or the lender’s office, you’re often rushed and swamped with documents. That’s exactly why it’s worth preparing your questions in advance, ideally even before the meeting. The lender must give you a product summary and a sheet explaining your rights: read them carefully. Here are the points to clarify:
- Who will receive the money, and will my family have flexibility?
- Will the amount covered decrease while my premium stays the same?
- What happens if I switch lenders or sell the house?
- What are the exclusions, particularly for pre-existing conditions?
- Do I already have group or individual insurance that covers this need?
- What would the total cost be over the full term of the loan?
Fictional example: Nadia and Thomas
Fictional example: Nadia and Thomas are buying their first home in Longueuil. At signing, they’re offered the lender’s life insurance. They take the time to meet with an advisor, who presents two scenarios. With the lender’s coverage, the amount paid at death decreases every year and goes directly to the lender. With personal term life insurance, the amount stays level, the surviving spouse is the beneficiary and the policy follows them even if they switch lenders in five years. The couple compares the benefits, exclusions and costs, then chooses the option that best meets their needs. The opposite choice could also have been reasonable depending on their situation.
If you’ve already enrolled in the lender’s insurance
Don’t panic. The Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) indicates that you have 10 days after buying insurance sold by a lender to cancel it; after that period, fees may apply. In any case, never cancel coverage before the new one is officially in force. That way, you’ll avoid a period without coverage.
You may also be insured twice, for example with individual insurance taken out later. Our article Lowering your insurance costs in Quebec: 9 practical ideas covers double coverage specifically.
Thinking beyond death
A mortgage is a long-term commitment. An illness or time off work can also make payments difficult. Before deciding, assess your disability insurance, which can pay a monthly income while you’re off work, and critical illness insurance, which pays a lump sum upon a covered diagnosis.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to take the life insurance offered by my bank?
No. This coverage is optional, and the lender cannot suggest that it’s required to get your loan or a better rate.
Can my personal life insurance be used to pay off the mortgage?
Yes. Your beneficiary can use the benefit to pay off the loan, or decide to use it another way if that’s more advantageous for the family.
Which option is best?
There’s no universal answer. It all depends on your health, your budget, your other coverage and your plans. Comparing like with like is the best way to decide.
Have your options compared
Are you buying a property in Montreal, Laval, Longueuil or elsewhere in Quebec, or renewing your mortgage? From our Saint-Leonard office, we compare the lender’s insurance and personal insurance with you, with no pressure. Request a free review of your insurance plan.
This article is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute personalized advice. Every situation is different: talk to a financial security advisor.
Get your insurance reviewed for free
Montreal, Laval, Terrebonne and everywhere in Quebec: leave your details and a financial security advisor will call you back to review your coverage. You can also book an appointment online or call 514 222 8633.
Also read: the insurance plan review.