Are you thinking about changing your life insurance because your premium is going up, your needs have changed or another offer looks more attractive? It’s possible, but a poorly planned replacement can leave you without coverage or cause you to lose benefits you’ve already earned. Here’s what you need to know before cancelling your current policy in Quebec.
Why people want to change their life insurance
The reasons are often legitimate. A family grows, a mortgage is paid off, a term premium comes up for renewal, or you realize the coverage never really matched your needs. Sometimes, you also receive an offer that looks more advantageous.
In every case, the right question isn’t just “is it cheaper?” but rather “will I be better protected, and on what terms?” A newer policy isn’t automatically better than one signed ten years ago.
Situations where a change may be justified
A replacement can make sense, for example, if your policy no longer covers the right amount, if its term no longer matches your obligations, if you quit smoking a long time ago or if your health has improved. It can also be worthwhile to combine several small policies into one. In each of these cases, the analysis must take your whole situation into account: your debts, your dependants, your other coverage and your budget. This big-picture view is what lets you decide whether to modify, supplement or replace.
The replacement notice: a tool to protect you
In Quebec, when a representative offers you a new insurance of persons contract that replaces all or part of an existing contract, they must complete a replacement notice with you, a form regulated by the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF).
This document is used to clearly compare the old and new policies. It includes, among other things:
- the type of policy, the coverage amounts and the premiums for each;
- the waiting periods and additional benefits;
- the reasons for the replacement and the possible disadvantages;
- the reasons why modifying the current policy was not chosen;
- the financial impact of the change.
The representative must explain it to you point by point, give you a signed copy and send a copy to the insurer whose policy is being replaced. If several policies are being replaced, a separate notice is required for each one. Take the time to read it: it’s your best protection against a rushed decision.
What you could lose by changing policies
The incontestability clause starts over
During the first two years of a policy, the insurer can contest a claim if information about your health or lifestyle was incomplete or inaccurate. If your current policy is more than two years old, this period is generally over. When you replace it, a new two-year period usually begins. All the more reason to fill out your new application with great accuracy.
The suicide clause also starts over
The same principle applies: the two-year suicide exclusion period generally starts again with the new policy.
Your age and health have changed
The new policy is priced based on your current age and current health. If your health has deteriorated since you signed your policy, a new insurer could apply an extra premium, exclude certain conditions or decline the application.
Benefits that are hard to find again
Some older policies include guarantees, conversion options or accumulated values that aren’t necessarily found in the products offered today. In the case of permanent insurance, cancelling can also have tax consequences; a tax specialist can advise you.
The golden rule: never cancel before the new policy is in force
This is the most costly mistake. Until the new policy is issued, accepted and in force, keep the old one. An application can be declined or accepted with different conditions than you hoped for. Cancelling too early could leave you and your family without protection.
Here’s a careful approach, in order:
- Have your current needs analyzed (debts, income to replace, dependants).
- Check whether your current policy can be modified: lowering the amount, converting it, adding or removing riders.
- If a replacement is justified, read the replacement notice carefully before signing.
- Wait for confirmation that the new policy has been issued and is in force.
- Read the new policy as soon as you receive it. Most insurers provide a period (often 10 days) to cancel it at no cost: ask your representative if this applies to you.
- Only then, cancel the old policy in writing.
Fictional example: replace or adjust?
Marc (a fictional character), 48, lives in Laval. For 12 years, he has held a $500,000 term life policy that is coming up for renewal. He’s offered a new policy. Before deciding, his advisor compares three options: renewing the current policy, converting part of the amount to permanent insurance, or taking out a new policy. Since Marc was diagnosed with high blood pressure two years ago, the pricing of a new policy could be different. The right choice will depend on this comparison, with equivalent benefits, and not on a single quoted premium.
If you’re in a similar situation, our article on renewing term life insurance explains the possible options.
Frequently asked questions
Can I change my life insurance at any time?
Yes, you’re free to replace your policy. However, make sure the replacement truly serves your interests and that the new policy is in force before cancelling the old one.
Will my current insurer be informed?
Yes. The representative must send a copy of the replacement notice to the insurer whose policy is being replaced.
Is it better to modify my policy than to replace it?
It’s often worth checking. Reducing the coverage amount, converting a term policy or removing a rider can meet your needs without starting from scratch.
Conclusion: compare before you cancel
Changing your life insurance can be a good decision, as long as you compare the benefits and never go without coverage. Before you sign, have your current life insurance reviewed along with your other protections, such as disability insurance. Whether you’re in Montreal, Laval, Terrebonne or elsewhere in Quebec, we offer a free review of your insurance plan.
This article is for information purposes only and does not constitute personalized advice. Every situation is different: talk to a financial security advisor.
Get your insurance reviewed for free
Montreal, Laval, Terrebonne and everywhere in Quebec: leave your details and a financial security advisor will call you back to review your coverage. You can also book an appointment online or call 514 222 8633.
Also read: the insurance plan review.