Monthly or annual premium: which way should you pay for your insurance?

Choosing between an annual or monthly insurance premium is mostly a matter of budget and organization. Paying annually can sometimes cost a little less overall, because some insurers add a charge for monthly payments, while monthly pre-authorized debits spread out the expense and make it easier to manage. Either way, what matters is that the premium is paid on time so your coverage stays in force.

Here’s how to compare the two options for your life, critical illness or disability insurance in Quebec.

Monthly or annual payment: what’s the difference?

The coverage is the same no matter how often you pay. What changes is how the money leaves your account:

  • Monthly premium: an amount automatically withdrawn from your bank account every month. This is the most common option for individual contracts.
  • Annual premium: a single payment per year, usually on the contract anniversary date.
  • Other frequencies: some contracts also allow quarterly or semi-annual payments. Ask about it, as it isn’t always offered.

Charges for paying monthly

Many insurers apply a modal factor: the total of 12 monthly payments can be slightly higher than the annual premium. This is due in part to administrative costs and to the fact that the insurer receives the money later. Other contracts have no difference at all. It all depends on the product.

How to check your contract

  1. Find the monthly premium and the annual premium in your application or contract summary.
  2. Multiply the monthly premium by 12.
  3. Compare the result with the annual premium. The difference is the cost of monthly flexibility.

If you can’t find the information, ask your advisor or the insurer’s customer service. You can also ask for it when getting a new quote.

Fictional example

The amounts below are fictional and are only meant to illustrate the calculation. They do not reflect any insurer’s rates.

Karim, from Terrebonne, has term life insurance. His application shows an annual premium of $480 or a monthly premium of $42. Over 12 months, the monthly payments total $504, or $24 more per year. Karim needs to ask himself whether that difference is worth the convenience of not paying $480 all at once. Since he receives a bonus every spring, the annual payment could fit well into his budget. For someone else with a tighter budget, monthly payments would be more realistic.

Budget and peace of mind: the advantages of each option

Why choose annual payment

  • The total cost may be slightly lower if the contract includes a modal charge.
  • Only one payment to keep track of each year.
  • Less risk of a missed payment due to a change of bank account during the year.

Why choose monthly payment

  • The expense is spread out and lines up with your paycheques.
  • Your emergency fund isn’t tied up by a large amount.
  • Automatic withdrawals mean you don’t have to think about it.

A simple tip if you’re unsure: set aside the equivalent of the premium each month in a separate savings account, then pay annually. You get the regularity of monthly payments while still having access to the annual premium. This method does, however, take discipline.

The risk of lapse for non-payment

This is the most important point, whatever frequency you choose. If a premium isn’t paid, the contract can end after the grace period set out by law and by the contract. This is called a lapse. Éducaloi outlines the main rules of life insurance in Quebec, and your contract sets out the exact terms.

The consequences of a lapse can be serious:

  • you are no longer covered, and neither are your loved ones;
  • reinstatement may require new health declarations, with no guarantee of acceptance;
  • if you need to take out a new contract, the premium will be set based on your current age and health.

Risky situations

Lapses often happen after a change of financial institution, an expired credit card, an account with insufficient funds or a move in which the insurer’s notices get lost. With annual payment, the risk is forgetting a due date that comes around only once a year. With monthly payment, it’s more likely a declined withdrawal that goes unnoticed.

To reduce this risk, update your banking and mailing information as soon as it changes, and open your insurer’s letters. If your finances become difficult, talk to your advisor quickly: there are sometimes options, such as adjusting your coverage, rather than letting the contract lapse.

Payment frequency: one lever among others

Changing your payment frequency usually has a modest effect on the total cost. If your goal is to better control what you pay, other factors often have more influence: the amount of coverage, the term, the riders you choose or the waiting period on disability insurance. Our article Lowering your insurance costs in Quebec: 9 practical ideas explores these levers. The Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) also outlines the steps to follow before getting insured.

Frequently asked questions

Can I change my payment frequency during the contract?

Often, yes. The change usually takes effect on a specific date, such as the contract anniversary. Contact your insurer or your advisor to find out the procedure.

What happens if a monthly withdrawal is declined?

The insurer usually notifies you and sometimes tries the withdrawal again. Act quickly to settle the situation before the grace period ends.

Does the payment method affect whether I’m accepted for insurance?

No. Acceptance depends on your profile (age, health, lifestyle), not on how often you pay.

To conclude

Monthly or annual, the best option is the one you can keep up without fail, year after year. Check the actual difference between the two in your contract, then choose based on your budget. Whether you’re in Montreal, Laval, Terrebonne or elsewhere in Quebec, you can request a free review of your insurance plan to take stock of your coverage and its cost.

This article is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute personalized advice. Every situation is different: talk to a financial security advisor.

Get your insurance reviewed for free

Montreal, Laval, Terrebonne and everywhere in Quebec: leave your details and a financial security advisor will call you back to review your coverage. You can also book an appointment online or call 514 222 8633.

Also read: the insurance plan review.

Scroll to Top