Critical illness insurance with return of premium: is it worth the cost?

A critical illness return of premium rider lets you get back part or all of the premiums you paid if you never made a claim, subject to certain conditions set out in the contract. In exchange, you pay a higher premium from the start. Whether it’s worth the cost depends mainly on your budget, your time horizon and your saving discipline.

In this article, we explain how this option available in Quebec works, what it really costs, who it may suit and what other options exist.

How the return of premium rider works

Critical illness insurance pays a lump sum if you are diagnosed with a covered condition (for example, certain cancers, a heart attack or a stroke) and survive the waiting period set out in the contract. Without a rider, if you never get sick, the premiums only pay for the coverage, just like home insurance.

The return of premium rider changes that logic. It provides that a portion of the premiums may be returned to you in certain situations. Terms vary from one contract to another, but there are generally three forms:

  • Return on cancellation: if you end the contract after a minimum number of years, part of the premiums is returned to you, often according to a schedule that increases over time.
  • Return at expiry: at an age or fixed date set out in the contract, you get back the eligible premiums if no benefit has been paid.
  • Return on death: if you die without having made a claim, the eligible premiums are paid to your beneficiaries.

Important: if you receive the critical illness benefit, the return of premium usually no longer applies. The two can rarely be combined.

What the rider really costs

The rider isn’t free. It can increase the premium significantly, sometimes by several tens of percent, depending on your age, the amount insured and the type of return you choose. So you need to look at two things: the extra monthly cost and the conditions for receiving the refund.

Conditions to read carefully

  • The number of years you must hold the contract before you’re entitled to a return on cancellation.
  • The percentage refunded depending on the year you cancel.
  • The premiums included: only the base premium, or also the premium for the rider and other options?
  • The effect of a partial claim (some contracts pay a small benefit for early-stage diagnoses, which can reduce the refund).

The opportunity cost

The money from the extra cost doesn’t earn interest for you during all those years. If you get back 100% of your premiums after 20 or 25 years, you recover the same number of dollars, but their purchasing power has been reduced by inflation. That’s something to compare with what the same amount could have grown to in a TFSA, for example.

Fictional example to illustrate the calculation

The following example is entirely fictional, and the amounts are only meant to illustrate the reasoning. They do not represent any insurer’s rates.

Julie, 35, lives in Laval. She is offered critical illness coverage with a base premium of $60 per month. With the return of premium at expiry rider, the premium would go up to $90 per month.

  1. The extra cost is $30 per month, or $360 per year.
  2. Over 25 years, Julie would pay about $27,000 in premiums with the rider.
  3. If she never makes a claim and keeps the contract until expiry, she could get back the eligible premiums according to her contract.
  4. If she cancels after 8 years, she might only get back a fraction, or nothing, depending on the schedule.

The real question for Julie: is she comfortable paying $30 more every month for years, and is she sure she’ll keep the contract long enough to benefit from the rider?

Who the rider may suit

This option is neither good nor bad in itself. It meets specific needs. It may be worth considering for someone who:

  • has a stable budget and can absorb the extra cost without cutting back on other essential coverage, such as disability insurance;
  • finds it hard to save regularly and appreciates a form of “forced” savings;
  • wants to keep their coverage for the long term and doesn’t plan to cancel it soon;
  • feels more comfortable knowing their premiums won’t be “lost.”

On the other hand, the rider is less suitable if your budget is tight, if you might change your contract in a few years, or if the extra cost forces you to choose a coverage amount that’s too low. It’s better to be well protected without the rider than underprotected with it.

Alternatives to consider

Before adding the rider, it’s worth comparing it with other options:

  • Keep the base premium and save the difference: you invest the amount saved yourself, for example in a TFSA. You keep your flexibility, but the discipline is up to you. Our investments page explains the main options.
  • Return on cancellation only: often less expensive than a full return at expiry, with a value that grows over time.
  • Adjust the amount or the term: well-targeted term coverage can meet your real need during the years when you’re most financially vulnerable.

To compare the contract’s other features (covered illnesses, definitions, exclusions), see our article on what to check when choosing critical illness insurance. The Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) also offers a guide on how to choose critical illness insurance.

Frequently asked questions

Is the return of premium taxable?

The tax treatment depends on how the contract is structured and on your situation. This is a technical question: a tax specialist or accountant can answer it based on your case.

Can I add the rider after taking out the policy?

Often, the rider must be chosen when you take out the policy. Some contracts may allow changes, but this isn’t guaranteed. Check before you sign.

If I make a claim, do I lose everything?

Generally, if the main benefit is paid, the return of premium no longer applies. However, you receive the amount provided for the covered illness, which is the very reason for having the insurance.

In summary

The return of premium rider can bring peace of mind, but it comes at a price and with specific conditions. The key is first to have the right amount of coverage, then to decide whether the extra cost fits into your long-term budget. Whether you’re in Montreal, Laval, Terrebonne or elsewhere in Quebec, you can request a free review of your insurance plan to compare options with and without the rider based on your situation.

This article is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute personalized advice. Every situation is different: talk to a financial security advisor.

Get your insurance reviewed for free

Montreal, Laval, Terrebonne and everywhere in Quebec: leave your details and a financial security advisor will call you back to review your coverage. You can also book an appointment online or call 514 222 8633.

Also read: the insurance plan review.

Scroll to Top